|
Obedience To Authority: Commands And Demands
The most direct way to influence the behavior of another person
is to demand that they do what you want. Unlike group pressures
to conform, which may be largely unspoken, direct commands or
orders leave little doubt about what the individual is supposed
to do. Obedience can be a normal and even functional part of our
lives. When we drive, for example, our safety depends on the fact
that other drivers will usually obey stop signs and traffic signals.
Military officers assume that the effectiveness of a fighting
force depends on the quick execution of orders by soldiers. Many
people believe that some degree of obedience to the legitimate
authority of a government or constitution is the hallmark of a
civilized society.
At the same time, the followers of David Koresh make it clear
that there is also a dark side to obedience. In fact, history
is littered with horrific acts committed by individuals who claimed
to have simply been "obeying orders." This issue was
brought dramatically into public awareness after World War II,
when many German officials and military officers were tried in
the city of Nuremberg for their participation in war crimes. These
crimes included their involvement in attempts to systematically
exterminate millions of European Jews, a period of genocide that
has come to be known as the Holocaust. People at the time were
outraged when the defendants explained the atrocities in which
they had taken part as simply the result of "following orders"
from their superiors. Their testimony raised public questions
about who bears the ultimate responsibility for acts of destructive
obedience. Under what circumstances can you be excused for harming
someone else when you have been ordered to do so? When does the
person giving such orders bear the responsibility?
|